The controversy surrounding pet cremation services is disturbing. Pet owners deserve answers, and anyone proven responsible for fraudulent practices must be held accountable.
But I strongly object to the growing narrative that veterinary clinics deliberately allow pets to die just to receive cash referral commissions from crematoriums.
That is a very serious accusation. Where is the evidence?
A veterinary clinic referring a deceased patient for cremation does not automatically mean there is a financial arrangement. And even if a referral fee exists, that alone does not establish that a veterinarian deliberately withheld treatment or caused an animal’s death.
Let us also address another disturbing statement: “Ang dami nang namamatay na pets ngayon sa clinics.”
Veterinary hospitals receive critically ill animals every day. Some arrive with advanced diseases, severe infections, organ failure, or life-threatening injuries.
Unfortunately, not every patient survives despite appropriate medical intervention.
A patient dying inside a veterinary hospital does not automatically mean veterinary negligence.
Figure 1. Excerpt from Mrs. Castro’s Facebook Post. The screenshot shows messages shared in Mrs. Castro’s Facebook post containing allegations that certain veterinary clinics allegedly allow pets to die and receive cash incentives for referring deceased animals to cremation providers. These allegations are serious because they question the professional integrity and ethical conduct of veterinarians. However, the identity of the individual making these claims, their firsthand knowledge, and the factual basis of their statements have not been independently verified. Publishing a screenshot does not automatically establish the truth of its contents. While legitimate complaints deserve investigation, allegations of deliberate animal deaths and financial misconduct require credible evidence before they can reasonably be treated as facts. The public should distinguish between verified wrongdoing, personal suspicion, and unsubstantiated accusations.
And suggesting that veterinarians intentionally allow animals to die for cremation commissions is an entirely different allegation requiring substantial evidence.
WE MUST DISTINGUISH THREE SEPARATE ISSUES:
- Alleged fraudulent cremation practices.
- Possible undisclosed financial arrangements between clinics and crematoriums.
- Allegations of veterinary negligence or deliberate withholding of treatment.
These are NOT interchangeable accusations.
If there is evidence of wrongdoing, present it to the appropriate authorities. Investigate. File formal complaints. Hold those responsible accountable.
But please stop turning the cremation controversy into a sweeping indictment of the veterinary profession.
Pet owners deserve justice. Veterinarians deserve due process. And the public deserves facts, not speculation.
We can demand accountability without destroying the reputation of an entire profession.
Because accusations are easy to post. Evidence is another matter.
Dr. Geoff Carullo is a Fellow and the current President of the Philippine College of Canine Practitioners.
Sharing this helps others understand what it really means to be a vet. Like and follow if you’re with us.
































